GR Yaris Ecutek, A-cams, & misfires

TheManWithTheStick

Totally Hooked
Joined
Dec 6, 2021
Messages
409
Reaction score
555
Location
Anglesey
Not sure where to start with this. Are any of you guys with Kelford A cams getting misfires at low RPM?

My car had final map with Litchfield at end of Oct. It wasn't the greatest experience if I'm honest but that's a story for another time.

The car has been running great but I recently changed my Ecutek dashboard to highlight low temperature things as blue until warmed and some things as red, such as high/low oil pressure and misfires > 0

To my surprise I started noticing a good few misfires! (Which sneakily seem to reset back to 0 after a few seconds, must be why I've never noticed before). But maybe this was always happening and I just never noticed.

I did notice that the misfires mainly happen at low revs - I'll see the odd one or two when driving normally but 0 when giving it full beans! Pulling in to my drive I'd see double digits of them!

I've found that just lifting the clutch in 1st or reverse and allowing the revs to rise to bite point is what causes it. I.e. when the idle goes a bit lumpy, which seems to be the norm with these cams?

I spoke to Litchfield who said to change plugs or coil packs. So I did both last week - no change, still misfiring at low load. So that was a waste of money. They then said to flash stock ROM and see if they still happen. I've just done that and moved around my drive for a few mins which did cause 1 misfire but took some doing. I then flashed my proper map back and there were 8 misfires just pulling out of my garage!

So I'm not sure what to do from here. Maybe someone with a similar setup could check if they're getting the same when manoeuvring slowly, like around a car park or something?

1000021529.webp

1000021530.webp
1000021531.webp
 
For what it's worth in terms of my own general experience, individual misfires don't tend to concern, it's clusters on a given cylinder that makes me nervous. That can indicate the start of a coil pack fault.
 
Thanks. I was told that Ecutek can't log which cylinder is misfiring but other ODB tools can? I scanned with Torque Pro and my OBDLink dongle but it said all was good and nothing logged. Plugged Ecutek dongle back in and there are the misfires. Which clear quickly. I noticed the Ecutek datalog doesn't list a misfire parameter at all! Unless I'm doing something wrong? So it can only be seen on the dashboards.

Like I say I changed all coils and plugs and the car feels exactly the same as before. It runs perfectly. I wouldn't know about any misfire if not for this dashboard counter.

It doesn't appear to be causing any problems so I'm not overly concerned, currently at least, but wondered if anyone else had seen it or might know more?
 
I'm getting a bit sick of the standard plugs and coils response from garages that can't/won't diagnose just to waste money. Shame to see Litchfield in that pack plus your other hint, not that I'd have been likely to be a customer of theirs anyway with closer options.
 
In fairness to them they did say they were happy for me to take it down there. Its just very inconvenient to do so and costs a few hundred quid before I even get to them (plus the last time was a complete waste of money and time).

So I guess I hope its just normal with these cams or something. Could the cams be installed wrong that might cause this? I don't see how that's possible and still have a working car, but what do I know. Any info is aporeciated.
 
Low misfire counts are no concern :) if you’re popping a CEL then you start hunting down for answers (coils, plugs, direct injector failures can sporadically happen early in our cars). Even though A cams aren’t considered a big cam, it is still bigger than stock and bigger cams don’t like to spend time at low rpms. My STI with Kelford 272 cams would constantly have misfire counts in the 1-3 range while idling. I’ll check my Ecutek to see what misfire counts I have since I have the same A cams as you :)
 
I think there's two elements. What degree of crank velocity change warrants a misfire on the dashboard Vs the ECU log? Then secondly how frequently and close together must miss fires be to trigger a CEL? It's possible the dashboard is much more sensitive in this respect, thus a red herring. You are asking the right questions however as the low speed cylinder filling might have changed on the bigger A cams. Ultimately if you have already renewed the whole ignition system and can't feel the miss fires at all they are likely inconsequential.
 
Thanks. I was told that Ecutek can't log which cylinder is misfiring but other ODB tools can? I scanned with Torque Pro and my OBDLink dongle but it said all was good and nothing logged. Plugged Ecutek dongle back in and there are the misfires. Which clear quickly. I noticed the Ecutek datalog doesn't list a misfire parameter at all! Unless I'm doing something wrong? So it can only be seen on the dashboards.

Like I say I changed all coils and plugs and the car feels exactly the same as before. It runs perfectly. I wouldn't know about any misfire if not for this dashboard counter.

It doesn't appear to be causing any problems so I'm not overly concerned, currently at least, but wondered if anyone else had seen it or might know more?
Ecutek definitely does capture the individual cylinder misfires so you can export a log and look at that to see which one(s) are being triggered over time.

IMG_8052.webp


And I found a dashboard I made which shows you can get this in the car too.

IMG_8056.webp
 
Last edited:
I just let my car idle now and I have zero misfires. I still think it’s nothing to be concerned about if there is no CEL :)
 
Not at idle but what if you lift the clutch to bite and inch forward or back? You might need to let it warm a bit first and try a few times please. I'm really hoping this is normal 🤞
 
Litchfield said they don't touch this part of the map this low down so it should work as stock. They also said there was a recent ProECU update which now shows the per-cylinder misfires, so they've sent a new logging profile over and I can see it's happening across all cylinders (but I'm not overly convinced with the accuracy of these counts)

1000021536.webp

1000021539.webp
1000021541.webp
1000021542.webp

1000021543.webp
1000021544.webp


Again, I don't really think this is an issue now but would love to know if I'm the only one seeing them or not.
 
Last edited:
I remember having a van chipped once. On driving the van away I immediately noticed that the feature of increasing fuel when lifting the clutch to reduce stalling had disappeared.
Sooo many layers to ECUs these days that has naturally increased their inherent complexity and (in my mind) difficulty with introducing a trouble free remap.
 
I remember having a van chipped once. On driving the van away I immediately noticed that the feature of increasing fuel when lifting the clutch to reduce stalling had disappeared.
Sooo many layers to ECUs these days that has naturally increased their inherent complexity and (in my mind) difficulty with introducing a trouble free remap.
The amount of complexity is mind boggling.

The best thing to do with that Denso ECU is remove and play cricket in the back yard. (just joking)
 
I think when we are getting this far into ECU TEC we are really pushing it. Syvecs or similar is the only real answer. My map from litchfield is great but it does sometimes hang the rpm when you come to a stop and it takes a good while to settle. Maybe that’s deliberate to prevent stalling with more ignition advance. I am at that cross roads. To go further it’s the artec turbo, but really I should then have syvecs and can you avoid forged rods and pistons, and head studs and cams. It’s a lot of change. After that you may as well have the x shift gearbox and for me that’s a dream car.
 
Hmm, I don't get any rev hang when I come to a stop. And my car runs perfectly except for these supposed misfires..

I'll be getting a turbo at some point too, and might consider Syvecs or Motec at that point, but I get the feeling the low down misfires may still be there with these cams.

I just want to know if I'm the only ones seeing them or not.
 
So you’ve never felt or heard a misfire just what the app is telling you?
 
Yep, exactly. Not a hiccup or anything untoward, it runs great and goes like hell with 0 misfires logged when on it. I even did a track day 2 weekends ago.

I have this dashboard active every time I drive the GR but only recently set the colours which is when I noticed this. It then took a while longer to figure out how to cause it with the low revs/bite point thing.

Litchfield have sent another map to try which I'll do tomorrow and update this.
 
I’ve observed this on stock cars as well as my own on Ecutek. So I don't think it's an Ecutek bug.

I'm inclined to say it's "normal" - because we don't touch cold start / idle maps either.

Best theory I have currently is that it's the motor running intentionally lean to warm up the catalytic converter for emissions and it's bouncing off the misfire margin.
 
Back
Top