To find answers for myself Iwas reading a lot, talking some engineers and wrote Toyota technical department. After some redirections I got an answer and put this together withe what I know and I was told bei experienced people who work with engine and in development.
My question in short:
What is the best breaking in procedure for the engine and why it's written in the manual as it is.
My short summary and answer:
1) The technical procedure in the manual is very simplified because the majority has to understand and comply to the description. (Statement of toyota)
2) these recommendations are more of a minimum not optimum for breaking in. It's a compromise between user friendliness, durability und engine performance. ( yes, you can run in for max performance or max durability)
3) engines are far less depending on propper engine breaking in then in times of cast iron blocks and bigger manufacturing tolerances.
4) Yes there is a difference but it's not so big anymore.
5) to soft breaking in produces an engine that is durable but a bit lethargic on power delivery.
6) to hard breaking in reduces durability, increasing wear and tear, increasing oil consumption and burning and reduces compression and therefore power.
7) performance engine breaking in procedure;
- Warm up engine. With varying 0 -25% throttle.
- Burst to about 50% throttle, hold rpm for several seconds, use engine breaking to slow down.
- Repeat several times.
- Repeat this for every gear. (If possible, high gear means high speed after all)
- Burst to about 75% throttle, hold for several seconds, use engine breaking to slow down.
- Repeat several times.
- Repeat this for every gear
- Burst to about 100% throttle, hold for several seconds, use engine breaking to slow down.
- Repeat several times.
- Repeat this for every gear
- change engine, diff and gearbox oil.
For street cars you can go on with:
- avoid constant engine speed for about 500 km
- increase max rpm slowly to redline over the 500 km.
8) the first few hours and kilometers are most important. After that it starts to fall off rapidly.
So that's what I do, and what I recommend, when I am asked. If someone wants to do it differently or has an other opinion, I am happily listening to their reasons and put this into my perspective. I may be wrong after all, but the above procedure is well known, I saw it proofed to work great in the past and after talking to some engineers it makes mechanical sense.
BUT things change. Engines change. So it's also a topic in change. But I have the feeling for some this is a more a religious thing than rational engineering. I would like to see a proper study with some same engines with different breaking in methods. But that would only apply to that engine than. So I guess we will never really see a real rational approach to this topic. It's to complicated after all. Do what makes most sense to you. Build you opinion on best knowledge and facts. Respect other opinions. Be open minded to learn new and change your opinion.
At the end it's a tiny little bit of a car and even less of your life. So don't over exaggerat it. That's what I am telling myself. To more ore less success.
