GR Yaris Case against a full decat

Status
Not open for further replies.
Two main ways to look at car emissions, only one I recently considered. CO2 etc output, green house gases, global warming bad.

And probably more direct acting particulates entering people lungs with the local area. I never considered this previously.

Emitted CO2 is a bit disconnected for the UK, I dare say. We aren’t going to be facing directly the heat and rising sea levels. But we will feel the issues in other ways.

I actually have a car which is getting another exhaust system and I’m paying £125 extra for a sport cat, but I do have the opportunity to pay £15 more on my MOT to “pass” without a cat.

I think de-catting / loud exhausts (more the latter) might hasten the downfall of ICE in the future. As younger generations think of ICE as a dirty old technology. So I try to ensure I don’t add to mix. A good example is a local person with a straight through exhaust that goes through town at 2am everynight, I’m sure they think the car sounds amazing but when the enitire town is trying to sleep, it definitely paints a bad pic for enthusiasts

Decat to me, is like removing the air filter to release a tad more power. Both cats and inlet filters are designed in a similar fashion , both to minimise pressure drop
 
Last edited:
There is the pollution element, we can all do our bit etc.

There is also the risk element. Removing the gpf or cat is illegal and will also void your insurance. What's the point in the risk for such insignificant gains? I will never see the point but plenty of others do. To each their own I guess.
 
...Removing the gpf or cat is illegal .....
Illegal in your country...

Regardless. I've went down the Golebys Racing Parts high flow 5 inch sports cat and the car never had a GPF in the first place.

The result of switching to a bigger dump pipe and high flow cat was certainly noticable, like how your car feels on a cold winters day and the car feels super punchy and responsive...like that.
 
There is the pollution element, we can all do our bit etc.

There is also the risk element. Removing the gpf or cat is illegal and will also void your insurance. What's the point in the risk for such insignificant gains? I will never see the point but plenty of others do. To each their own I guess.
The risk is miniscule, it's never going to be picked up in a traffic stop.

The gain is subjective isn't it, for the cost of the part and ease of fitment, it's definitely worth it for me in terms of enjoyment. I also just enjoy modifying the car to improve it/making it my own anyway.
 
The risk is miniscule, it's never going to be picked up in a traffic stop.

The gain is subjective isn't it, for the cost of the part and ease of fitment, it's definitely worth it for me in terms of enjoyment. I also just enjoy modifying the car to improve it/making it my own anyway.
I know it's kind of a doomsday scenario, but if you were in an accident, someone was hurt, due to the seriousness of the accident your car was immediately taken away, your insurance inspect the car to find it is not road legal..........you can imagine the rest. As you say maybe the risk is small, it's just not one I would ever be willing to take for a few bhp.
 
Its a 1.6. Cat or no Cat, in the big picture the impact it has on the world is essentially zero. Sorry if you don't like that but its true.

I decided to have a little fun on my lunch hour (what a boring life I must have hey!)

Say an average decat'd GR Yaris does 10,000km a year and we use C02 as a benchmark of the % contribution of each car to the global man made emissions...

Global C02 Emissions (pre covid say 2019)
36,700,000,000t

GR YARIS
186g/km or 0.000186t/kg x 10,000km = 1.86t/year.

Each GR Yaris represents a contribution to global emissions of 0.000,000,005%

SO...if we go back to the pool analogy for global emissions (lets use a swimming pool) and the "turd" being the impact of a decat'd Yaris....

Volume of olympic swimming pool 2,500,000L ...0.000,000,005% of that equates to 0.127cm3 of turd...SO what you're actually saying (when you remove the "someone think of the kids!? OH NO OH MY!!! THE HORROR") from the analogy, is when someone decats a car, they have, AT MOST the impact of introducing a flea sized turd into an olympic sized swimming pool.

SO there we have it. Decat = a flea sized turd in a swimming pool. Hardly seems worth worrying about does it? Not when every kid in there is pissing in it, (lets call them all China).

Actually the cat doesn't have anything to do with CO_2 emissions, it even raises the CO_2 emission a bit. The catalytic converter is mainly there to reduce unburned hydrocarbons, carbon monoxide and nitrogen oxides and convert them into CO_2, water and nitrogen. Those three pollutants are highly toxic and as Onehp said are causing the death of people locally not globally.

The global impact of the GPF is completely irrelevant, it is mainly important for people in densly populated areas. If you're living in the deepest outback in Australia do your thing but theres a reason heavy populated countries like the EU are following stricter rules.

I wanted to wait with my first post in this forum until my GRY arrives but your post just misses the point so much I had to respond.
 
Actually the cat doesn't have anything to do with CO_2 emissions, it even raises the CO_2 emission a bit. The catalytic converter is mainly there to reduce unburned hydrocarbons, carbon monoxide and nitrogen oxides and convert them into CO_2, water and nitrogen. Those three pollutants are highly toxic and as Onehp said are causing the death of people locally not globally.

The global impact of the GPF is completely irrelevant, it is mainly important for people in densly populated areas. If you're living in the deepest outback in Australia do your thing but theres a reason heavy populated countries like the EU are following stricter rules.

I wanted to wait with my first post in this forum until my GRY arrives but your post just misses the point so much I had to respond.
The C02 was meant as an analogy for contribution. But even so its indeed incorrect as local pollution contribution works completely different. Actually, the no1 possible victim is the owner/driver themselves... So it's for our own sake too 😘 @Gazooracingyaris
 
Last edited:
Actually the cat doesn't have anything to do with CO_2 emissions, it even raises the CO_2 emission a bit. The catalytic converter is mainly there to reduce unburned hydrocarbons, carbon monoxide and nitrogen oxides and convert them into CO_2, water and nitrogen. Those three pollutants are highly toxic and as Onehp said are causing the death of people locally not globally.

The global impact of the GPF is completely irrelevant, it is mainly important for people in densly populated areas. If you're living in the deepest outback in Australia do your thing but theres a reason heavy populated countries like the EU are following stricter rules.

I wanted to wait with my first post in this forum until my GRY arrives but your post just misses the point so much I had to respond.
Who said it did? I didn't. I said..
"...we use C02 as a benchmark of the % contribution of each car to the global man made emissions..."

I wasnt going to reply but your misinterpretation of my post was so wrong I had to respond.
 
Illegal in your country...

Regardless. I've went down the Golebys Racing Parts high flow 5 inch sports cat and the car never had a GPF in the first place.
You have a cat so my OP wasn't even directed at your case. You're doing fine ;)
 
Last edited:
Who said it did? I didn't. I said..
"...we use C02 as a benchmark of the % contribution of each car to the global man made emissions..."

I wasnt going to reply but your misinterpretation of my post was so wrong I had to respond.
It's just wrong to downplay the effect of removing the cat by doing some math with global emissions. For your analogy with the turd in the swimming pool you need to take the environment the GRY is used in, and compare the emissions of hydrocarbons, carbon monoxide or nitrogen oxides in this exact environment. And this will be more than a flea sized turd if you remove the cat. Theres a reason older diesel models and aren't allowed in many cities anymore and developed countries don't allow the homologation of two-stroke engines.
 
It's just wrong to downplay the effect of removing the cat by doing some math with global emissions. For your analogy with the turd in the swimming pool you need to take the environment the GRY is used in, and compare the emissions of hydrocarbons, carbon monoxide or nitrogen oxides in this exact environment. And this will be more than a flea sized turd if you remove the cat. Theres a reason older diesel models and aren't allowed in many cities anymore and developed countries don't allow the homologation of two-stroke engines.
🤣
1)not my analogy.
2)im going to drop this conversation right here if you cant admit you read my post wrong and you're now trying to change tack.
 
Again, chill out on this thread or it will be locked.
This is an international forum, with different legislation in different countries and drivers dotted all over the world.

Get on, or move on.
Wonderful advice. Peace out! 😊👍
 
Whilst this thread was started seemingly by someone who had some kind of agenda to push, and wasn't directly about climate change, I would urge anyone to watch the following video. It's more well researched and better presented than any other video on climate change I've ever watched. It's changed the way I think about it all anyway.






All their other videos are great too 👌
 
Whilst this thread was started seemingly by someone who had some kind of agenda to push
Uhm, yeah, I don't like people dying of cancer and see *not* decatting as a terribly effective way in contributing to that.

As for climate change, my Yaris is my big black sheep but I hope to run it on efuel as it comes available, even at a premium...
 
If that doesn't work out you could always just ride round on your high horse :p
How did you know, that I'm really good a horseback riding? Let me explain.






Don't read threads you don't like ;)



And actually, you can watch the vid posted by @GRY_CAA, it adresses the feeling you have.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top