GR Yaris Case against a full decat

Status
Not open for further replies.

Onehp

Totally Hooked
Joined
Dec 6, 2021
Messages
3,386
Reaction score
5,709
Location
Svveden
Some thoughts as I see more decats showing up.

It's illegal. The end.

But why?

Not really why, but in this case it's quite literally full not nice!

Why?

Full decat removes decades of progress in cleaner emissions resulting in emission levels that can be ballpark hundredfold that of a properly catted modern car.

Why care about that?

Well it's not as dramatic as shooting someone in public, but emissions do kill people with various forms of cancer, one of the biggest killers we know, just we can never tell where 'which bullit killed who' sometimes decades later.

It kinda sucks that one persons bad decision can nullify the efforts of so many others to keep air kinda clean-ish...


But performance??

Well, actually a high flow sports cat will flow near as well and while not as good as OE emissions control, emission wise it will be far from as disastrous as a full decat. Looking forward to some proper highflow catted aftermarket solutions for those that must have highest possible power (CSK race?) i.e. for racing, sprints etc. For road use there is also a fully legal choice for sportscats (HJS) and so far it looks like they are pretty effective considering it's just one part of two emission parts replaced with ~10hp gain, instead of entirely removing two that gains less than 20hp on stock tune...

Feel free to discuss...

Edited to be kind
 
Last edited by a moderator:
I honestly don‘t understand why people will decat or degpf (is that a word?) a car which they drive on the street.
The performance gain is not that big compared to a street legal sportcat like the HJS for example.
And i‘m absolutely sure, the joy of driving a car, no matter which one, if it’s a McLaren 765LT or a GR Yaris, isn‘t bigger if you have 310hp Instead of 300hp or 775hp instead of 765hp, you get in full legal trim.

That‘s why i drive the OEM exhaust with a HJS Downpipe on the street all the time.

On the racetrack it‘s something completely different.
There i want as much free flow as i can get to reduce the stress for the engine, the turbo and get as much power as possible.
Especially when you‘re competing against others, every hp counts.
 
Last edited:
Decat to me, on a used car, to me says “hey I couldn’t afford to fit a sports cat, probably some other leggy bits in the car aswell”

Decat only increases peak HP as well surely? I drive most of time at low or mid rpm where I suspect % torque difference is minimal , cat vs decat.

Also decat’s make more noise, which I think of as a negative (assuming you already have a cat back aftermakerket exhaust ).

A massive hassle for MOT, if you can get one to pass then what else has been overlooked.

Now hear is my hypocrisy, motorcycles, mine don’t have cats but they were made in early 90s before cats were a thing on bikes. And I used them less.

A decat on a daily driver, where you can be sat in traffic a lot (different from bikes) to me, really is selfish. But I also view people who drive 1 mile or under to the shops or school (regularly) selfish
 
Agree with this. not a fan of either decat or excessive noise on the street.

The performance gains are marginal and really only of benefit at the higher end of the rev range, whereas the environmental damage and annoyance of neighbours and the general public is constant.

I'm reminded of high performance diesels a few years back that would belch clouds of particulates like this. Amusing at the time, but now we look and don't feel so comfortable with the emissions. I suspect we'd have a similar reaction to emissions from decatted vehicles if we could see them.

It amuses (that's not the right word but I'll stick with it for now) me when looking at American groups that decatting and fitting loud systems to cars and bikes almost seems like a religion, because "freedom" and clearly any form of environmental protection is obviously Democrat and therefore Communist.

I worry too that a lot of the campaigns to reduce vehicle noise levels further and further are not a response to current OEM systems, but are a reaction to noisy aftermarket and decatted systems.


(Full disclosure; I have decatted vehicles in the past and, having realised the error of my ways, have subsequently replaced the cats etc back to OEM spec)
 
A methaphore

Here in Sweden at least it's mandatory to shower and soap up all body parts before entering a public swimming pool.

Decat: takes a dump in his trunks while in the pool...

:cautious:
 
When I ordered the car I was totally aware that this car has 100hp less than my current car so it's not a problem, no need to delete cat's or anything. Nothing against tuning when done properly, but removing cat's or other emission stuff for few horsepowers is the wrong way. Also just thowing aftermarket parts on a car is also pretty stupid. One guy on fb said he needs to reset the check engine light every time he drives because he deleted the cat. That's just dumb. In general if you don't have full control over the ecu it's pretty hacky to do anything IMO.
 
Just to add that a decatted petrol car is not entirely ‘invisible’. I cycle to work most days and my least favourite vehicles to pass are leggy VAG oil burners (Passats, A4s etc), old transits and…decatted boy racer shitboxes. It’s made worse by the fact that they always have to pin it when overtaking as I may have held them to the speed limit for a second or two. I try and hold my breath but when you get a lungful of this it’s not nice.

I love the smell of petrol, Castrol R etc. but what comes out the tailpipes is nasty, there’s no need to make it even nastier.

Just get a sports cat you filthy peasants.
 
Its a 1.6. Cat or no Cat, in the big picture the impact it has on the world is essentially zero. Sorry if you don't like that but its true.

I decided to have a little fun on my lunch hour (what a boring life I must have hey!)

Say an average decat'd GR Yaris does 10,000km a year and we use C02 as a benchmark of the % contribution of each car to the global man made emissions...

Global C02 Emissions (pre covid say 2019)
36,700,000,000t

GR YARIS
186g/km or 0.000186t/kg x 10,000km = 1.86t/year.

Each GR Yaris represents a contribution to global emissions of 0.000,000,005%

SO...if we go back to the pool analogy for global emissions (lets use a swimming pool) and the "turd" being the impact of a decat'd Yaris....

Volume of olympic swimming pool 2,500,000L ...0.000,000,005% of that equates to 0.127cm3 of turd...SO what you're actually saying (when you remove the "someone think of the kids!? OH NO OH MY!!! THE HORROR") from the analogy, is when someone decats a car, they have, AT MOST the impact of introducing a flea sized turd into an olympic sized swimming pool.

SO there we have it. Decat = a flea sized turd in a swimming pool. Hardly seems worth worrying about does it? Not when every kid in there is pissing in it, (lets call them all China).
 
Last edited:
Its a 1.6. Cat or no Cat, in the big picture the impact it has on the world is essentially zero. Sorry if you don't like that but its true.

I have two simple answers two this very common attitude so thanks for bringing it to the light. One philosophical and one mathematical.


Philosophical
One can go through life either thinking that ones actions make a difference, or that they don't, but you don't get to cherrypick, it's either or.

So let's say I think mine do and you think yours don't, well that basically means that I'm right and you're wrong. Why did you even bother to write something? And if life/karma/whatever gives you sh*t, you don't matter by your own admission so I hope you don't put much energy in complaining, because I hate that 'noise'.


Mathematical
We're currently, roughly, 8,000,000,000 persons on this planet.

At least I want to live on a planet where these 8,000,000,000 persons think their actions matter, rather than having every single of these 8,000,000,000 think they don't make a difference. How depressing that would be. HUGE difference.


Oh I lied. There is a third answer.
I'm actually not going into that pool knowing someone is spreading around parts of his/her turd though his/her trunks, but you please go ahead and tell your fellow 'enthusiasts' to join in on the 'fun' in your pool, as the emissions relevant here are local. By analogy, I'm happy to live in a clean-ish organised city and not in a smog ridden mega traffic jam that's also known as a "city". I might have even contributed to my clean one, who knows, but it wasn't just me...

Thanks for reading ;)
 
Last edited:
I took my GPF off because I have asthma, and thoroughly recommend it to everyone else.
🤔

1649138824216.webp
 
Totally with you Onehp.

Cat delete and GPF delete are like walking down a street, middle fingers up shouting at every one kicking every one's shin. You'd say that's an asshole.

Remus gpf delete sound brutally awesome. I like it but never would fit it the car. I don't want anyone taking harm (lungs/ears/stress) for my likings.
 
I took my GPF off because I have asthma, and thoroughly recommend it to everyone else.
I'd also recommend cutting two holes in the roof and put hoses on the exhaust tips and connect them to said holes. I guarantee you will soon be completely ridden of your astma!
 
I have two simple answers two this very common attitude so thanks for bringing it to the light. One philosophical and one mathematical.


Philosophical
One can go through life either thinking that ones actions make a difference, or that they don't, but you don't get to cherrypick, it's either or.

So let's say I think mine do and you think yours don't, well that basically means that I'm right and you're wrong. Why did you even bother to write something? And if life/karma/whatever gives you sh*t, you don't matter by your own admission so I hope you don't put much energy in complaining, because I hate that 'noise'.


Mathematical
We're currently, roughly, 8,000,000,000 persons on this planet.

At least I want to live on a planet where these 8,000,000,000 persons think their actions matter, rather than having every single of these 8,000,000,000 think they don't make a difference. How depressing that would be. HUGE difference.


Oh I lied. There is a third answer.
I'm actually not going into that pool knowing someone is spreading around parts of his/her turd though his/her trunks, but you please go ahead and tell your fellow 'enthusiasts' to join in on the 'fun' in your pool, as the emissions relevant here are local. By analogy, I'm happy to live in a clean-ish organised city and not in a smog ridden mega traffic jam that's also known as a "city". I might have even contributed to my clean one, who knows, but it wasn't just me...

Thanks for reading ;)
Only an asshole deals in absolutes, you may want to consider that for a while.

Maybe some actions matter and others don't.

I assume you don't go in any pool ever then? Because let me tell you outright. That chlorine smell?... isn't chlorine.

Again, only an asshole deals in absolutes.
 
Apologies if anyone feels attacked personally in case some of my wording was less then sensitive.

I do admit I feel quite strongly about the matter. Not in the least I have also been guilty to, nicely put, not thinking it through having done at least one decat myself, and I don't hate myself for it nor do I hate others for it. Nor should anyone spread division on a matter as this. Other then fail a MOT :)

So not meant absolutist at all (unless saying it matters vs saying it doesn't matter at all makes it absolute?), just a clear and fact based opinion and a wish to inform on the matter as I believe it can make our common interest a bit less harmful.
 
Last edited:
I used to Sprint my Evo6 with a Decat, but always a pain refitting the Cat for MOT.
In the end I fitted a Blitz Sports Cat and it passed MOT's and lost no performance (Still 360 bhp, I was very surprised).

There are now free flowing Euro6 Compliant Sports Cats and OPF's for the GR Yaris, so if you want to get the best gains possible, then that's the legal way around the issue.
 
Personally I justify removing my GPF to myself by two main things, firstly the fact that most GR Yaris don't have GPFs anyway. And also whatever car I would have got in its place almost certainly wouldn't have had a GPF either.

I intend to keep the cat in place but it's only really the engine management faff that's making me do that, ultimately that's what it comes down to for me. If there were direct negative consequences for removing the GPF, that would probably still be in place too.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top