Replaced the all seasons with the new Asymmetric 6 from goodyear. Theoretically lower grip then PS4S but not much, but definitely 'lower dry grip' then many aftermarket choices. In my case being 235 on a 17x9 inch rim they are quite balloony and initially they feel good at a relatively high 2,4 bar all round, and that should help reduce grip a bit and also any parasite noises. Will see if I up it a bit further later on without them getting skittish.
Grip is maybe bit higher then I ideally wanted, but analysing test data, the difference is minimal to the Nankang mentioned higher up and it's a better tyre on all other properties that also matter, I didn't fancy paying near enough the same money for a chinese tyre, the GY were great value. And at approx 9kg it's a light tyre and it does feel it too.
I'll have to work up my driving skills some more to compensate for some lost playfullness, but grip communication is up for sure, a fair trade-off. And so far, no squealing in enthusiastic curve taking at higher ambients, which was a bit of a deal breaker with the all seasons....