I'm right there with you. I can't stand digital dashboards like the ones in the new BMWs and other cars. They look so tacky. I mean, the retro digital dash look on the MK2 isn't as bad as some others, but it's still digital and it just doesn't have the feel of classic analog gauges.
One of the main reasons I went for the MK1 was because of its analog gauges, believe it or not. The simpler, the better. They look perfect to me and remind me so much of the B5 RS4 gauges. The best thing about analog gauges is they never look outdated or old. They age really well, while digital dashboards quickly look old-fashioned, even the ones trying to look "retro" with a square design.
Something no one talks about is how much easier on the eyes analog gauges are. That's never going to change. Digital gauges, no matter how much anti-glare coating they have, are always more distracting and worse for your eyes, whether they're LCD or LED.
The only upside of digital gauges is that they can be customized to show different screens, making them easier to read on the track, but that hardly matters since 99.9% of the time, these cars are driven on regular roads.
IMO, analog gauges = timeless
…or I’m just old