Hi!
I am new here and hoping for some honest and constructive input from your side
I will be buying a new car within the next few weeks and I am in a big dilemma here
The two candidates are the GR Yaris (reason why I m here) and the A110. I am currently driving an R56 JCW and before that - a 106 Rallye (so you get the idea of the type of cars that are of interest to me)
Here of course, I will be concerned only about the first candidate, hence I would like to avoid any arguments of the type "this is better than the other" etc etc
Despite having different philosophy, both cars are amazing, are driver's enthousiast machines and both have their pros and cons. I have already done a great deal of research for both, but any input from you guys is super important, as no research can be a substitute for input from a long term owner
In order to be more constructive here, I ll focus on specific questions, which are still areas of concern for me
First and foremost is the gearbox. Up until now, I ve been driving manual all my life. And although I am not particularly open minded let's say about many of the latest tech added to cars over more recent years, and although I m exclusively aquiented and enjoying using manual, I am seriously considering the auto gear option for the Yaris. The paddles still offer the opportunity to manually shift (otherwise I wouldn't ever consider the auto version), offer faster gear changes and also are more easy to live with when you are stuck in traffic. I have already had my first test drive with a Gen2 auto and although I have heard many comments about that newly introduced auto not being as snappy (e.g. as opposed to a PDK), it seemed to be acceptably responsive to me. Of course coming exclusively from manual boxes, I find the paddles somewhat ackward, but I suppose this is just a matter of practice till I feel like home. Another assumption that I have for the auto gearbox is that it could be lasting longer compared to a manual, as the gear changes are handled essentially by the car and leave no margin for error (as opposed to improper use of driver/manual clutch+gear shift). But this is just my assumption. On the Toyota website, it states that fuel consumption is marginally increased on the auto vs the manual, but this is not a concern for me. As for the gear ratios on the auto, I found them to be very nice. During my test drive on the highway 235km can be reached on 7th (having just 5000rpm!). So I see that the 8th gear is purely for 'comfort' cruising on highway. This thing really is alive from 4000rpm+ up till 7000rpm, so there was even 2000rpm more that you never have to use since the top speed is reached already. I have already requested to test also the manual box, but Toyota is struggling to find a Gen2 manual anywhere near my area
So, here are my questions about the gearbox (which are applicable for those of you who had the Gen2 auto for several months ideally):
a) Is that 8-speed auto reliable in the long term?
b) Regarding the lack of 'responsiveness' (especially downshifts), do you have any remarks? (and if there are, I m not sure if those where addressed via software updates or are a matter of hardware which means the gearbox behavior cannot be changed/improved once it is released)
The other area of concern is the engine, which based on specs, is nothing short of a miracle. I have been reading reports for a small fraction of Gen1 cars having blowups, but also same sources confirm that this rare issue was mitigated on the Gen2. During my test drive I was impressed on how such a small engine can pull and be revved up without dying out in the top end. Questions:
a) Reliability-wise - any concerns on that upgraded Gen2 engine so far? I am taking into account that the service intervals are done properly and on time, car with no mods/remaps, and properly warmed up/cooled down. For most ordinary Toyota cars out there, engines would last a lifetime. But since this is not a normal engine but instead is build on motorsport tech, is that longevity still there? Even if I treat the engine right, can I expect this engine to last 200K km or more? I mean the service interval (every 10000km) is pretty short, but at least if done, should I expect the engine to meet the reknown Toyota reliability standards?
b) Temperatures. During my test runs, on the high speed ones I have observed coolant/oil temps around the early 100Cs. There is a gauge for each of these values and seemed to be well below max. Therefore is safe to assume that stock cooling seems to be sufficient for most road usage - but what about occasional track days? Is the stock intercooler / oil cooling sufficient or do you really need an aftermarket solution (I have no intention of tracking the car for at least the 1st big service, but just to know for future reference)
c) Last, but probably THE most important for me - oil consumption. Coming from the R56 JCW (which drank oil almost as much as fuel), what should I expect from this 3pot 1.6lt turbo engine? Again, taking into assumption that the car is treated carefully (as mentioned above). What is the typical oil consumption (e.g. ML per 1000km) that I should expect (with just spirited road usage, but no track)?
d) Which leads me to the next question regarding the engine - any of you with a Gen2 have installed an oil catch can? I am not at all fond of having any mods, especially on a brand new car and also because when I asked the Toyota dealer, even such a mod would possibly void the warranty. But having/maintaing an engine in a better state in the long term, with less carbon buildup is also very important. I am not particularly technically savvy, but from what I understood, those gasses are fed back into the intake for enviromental purposes only (i.e. as it would be very polluting to have them out on the road) and not so because oil vapours are good for the intake(!) So the use of an oil catch can makes sense to me. Reputable aftermarket solutions e.g. GReddy (part code: 13510603) could be an improvement for this aspect - what are your thoughts? Is there really any drawback with using an oil catch can (other than the warranty void)?
e) What is the typical cost for the 10000km service interval, and what do they usually change? (I live in Germany)
Regarding trim protection - if I purchase the car, I plan to do the treatment coating for the underside protection, against corrosion (e.g. the solvents that they apply on the roads during winter/snow), but also plan for ceramic coating, in order to protect the car from chips
a) Is there any special precaution I need to consider regarding the ceramic coating specifically for the GR Yaris? Not so much about doors/hood/bonnet (aluminium), but what about the carbon roof? Is ceramic coating still applicable there or another solution (e.g. film) would be more appropriate? I have no experience in detailing, other than some basic clay/sealant I used to do on my MINI
x) Finally, I would like to check some costs for typical parts. For the MINI, I ve been using realoem.com - what's the equivelent one for Toyota?
Thank you very much in advance for any input
p.s. it would be most helpful for any feedback that you provide, you state for which question you refer to
I am new here and hoping for some honest and constructive input from your side
I will be buying a new car within the next few weeks and I am in a big dilemma here
The two candidates are the GR Yaris (reason why I m here) and the A110. I am currently driving an R56 JCW and before that - a 106 Rallye (so you get the idea of the type of cars that are of interest to me)
Here of course, I will be concerned only about the first candidate, hence I would like to avoid any arguments of the type "this is better than the other" etc etc
Despite having different philosophy, both cars are amazing, are driver's enthousiast machines and both have their pros and cons. I have already done a great deal of research for both, but any input from you guys is super important, as no research can be a substitute for input from a long term owner
In order to be more constructive here, I ll focus on specific questions, which are still areas of concern for me
First and foremost is the gearbox. Up until now, I ve been driving manual all my life. And although I am not particularly open minded let's say about many of the latest tech added to cars over more recent years, and although I m exclusively aquiented and enjoying using manual, I am seriously considering the auto gear option for the Yaris. The paddles still offer the opportunity to manually shift (otherwise I wouldn't ever consider the auto version), offer faster gear changes and also are more easy to live with when you are stuck in traffic. I have already had my first test drive with a Gen2 auto and although I have heard many comments about that newly introduced auto not being as snappy (e.g. as opposed to a PDK), it seemed to be acceptably responsive to me. Of course coming exclusively from manual boxes, I find the paddles somewhat ackward, but I suppose this is just a matter of practice till I feel like home. Another assumption that I have for the auto gearbox is that it could be lasting longer compared to a manual, as the gear changes are handled essentially by the car and leave no margin for error (as opposed to improper use of driver/manual clutch+gear shift). But this is just my assumption. On the Toyota website, it states that fuel consumption is marginally increased on the auto vs the manual, but this is not a concern for me. As for the gear ratios on the auto, I found them to be very nice. During my test drive on the highway 235km can be reached on 7th (having just 5000rpm!). So I see that the 8th gear is purely for 'comfort' cruising on highway. This thing really is alive from 4000rpm+ up till 7000rpm, so there was even 2000rpm more that you never have to use since the top speed is reached already. I have already requested to test also the manual box, but Toyota is struggling to find a Gen2 manual anywhere near my area
So, here are my questions about the gearbox (which are applicable for those of you who had the Gen2 auto for several months ideally):
a) Is that 8-speed auto reliable in the long term?
b) Regarding the lack of 'responsiveness' (especially downshifts), do you have any remarks? (and if there are, I m not sure if those where addressed via software updates or are a matter of hardware which means the gearbox behavior cannot be changed/improved once it is released)
The other area of concern is the engine, which based on specs, is nothing short of a miracle. I have been reading reports for a small fraction of Gen1 cars having blowups, but also same sources confirm that this rare issue was mitigated on the Gen2. During my test drive I was impressed on how such a small engine can pull and be revved up without dying out in the top end. Questions:
a) Reliability-wise - any concerns on that upgraded Gen2 engine so far? I am taking into account that the service intervals are done properly and on time, car with no mods/remaps, and properly warmed up/cooled down. For most ordinary Toyota cars out there, engines would last a lifetime. But since this is not a normal engine but instead is build on motorsport tech, is that longevity still there? Even if I treat the engine right, can I expect this engine to last 200K km or more? I mean the service interval (every 10000km) is pretty short, but at least if done, should I expect the engine to meet the reknown Toyota reliability standards?
b) Temperatures. During my test runs, on the high speed ones I have observed coolant/oil temps around the early 100Cs. There is a gauge for each of these values and seemed to be well below max. Therefore is safe to assume that stock cooling seems to be sufficient for most road usage - but what about occasional track days? Is the stock intercooler / oil cooling sufficient or do you really need an aftermarket solution (I have no intention of tracking the car for at least the 1st big service, but just to know for future reference)
c) Last, but probably THE most important for me - oil consumption. Coming from the R56 JCW (which drank oil almost as much as fuel), what should I expect from this 3pot 1.6lt turbo engine? Again, taking into assumption that the car is treated carefully (as mentioned above). What is the typical oil consumption (e.g. ML per 1000km) that I should expect (with just spirited road usage, but no track)?
d) Which leads me to the next question regarding the engine - any of you with a Gen2 have installed an oil catch can? I am not at all fond of having any mods, especially on a brand new car and also because when I asked the Toyota dealer, even such a mod would possibly void the warranty. But having/maintaing an engine in a better state in the long term, with less carbon buildup is also very important. I am not particularly technically savvy, but from what I understood, those gasses are fed back into the intake for enviromental purposes only (i.e. as it would be very polluting to have them out on the road) and not so because oil vapours are good for the intake(!) So the use of an oil catch can makes sense to me. Reputable aftermarket solutions e.g. GReddy (part code: 13510603) could be an improvement for this aspect - what are your thoughts? Is there really any drawback with using an oil catch can (other than the warranty void)?
e) What is the typical cost for the 10000km service interval, and what do they usually change? (I live in Germany)
Regarding trim protection - if I purchase the car, I plan to do the treatment coating for the underside protection, against corrosion (e.g. the solvents that they apply on the roads during winter/snow), but also plan for ceramic coating, in order to protect the car from chips
a) Is there any special precaution I need to consider regarding the ceramic coating specifically for the GR Yaris? Not so much about doors/hood/bonnet (aluminium), but what about the carbon roof? Is ceramic coating still applicable there or another solution (e.g. film) would be more appropriate? I have no experience in detailing, other than some basic clay/sealant I used to do on my MINI
x) Finally, I would like to check some costs for typical parts. For the MINI, I ve been using realoem.com - what's the equivelent one for Toyota?
Thank you very much in advance for any input
p.s. it would be most helpful for any feedback that you provide, you state for which question you refer to
