I didn't touch the kidney resonator. Only the big resonator adjacent to the airbox, before the air filter.No perceptible loss in performance as far as i can tell for that resonator beside the airbox (and i reckon since it is upstream of the filter element, any helmholtz effect would be further damped by the filter anyway.
As for the kidney shaped resonator, some people say there is a difference. Even HKS in their marketing materials justifying why they kept that even with their CAI. I didnt do any before and after. In fact a year back, i bought the mishimoto silicone tube (that goes from after the stock air filter box to the throttle body) that retains this kidney resonator for the exact reason i didn't want a loss in performance.
But thats all behind me now since i have the big ass GR Intake (which doesnt have any resonator and in fact changes the air intake length somewhat). But also cant tell any difference. Maybe i have a numb butt hahaha
I did AB testing with and without the big resonator. I swear I'm losing that "kick" at around 3K+ rpm without the resonator. I personally liked the look of the engine bay without the resonator. But my butt dyno disagrees with the decision. Shame, cause I liked the induction noise.
I feel the big resonator acts like a hammer arrestor that buffers the returning air shockwaves when a valve closes. But since the resonator is before the filter, the filter should be absorbing any returning shockwaves.
