@6mt and
@Galerion and anyone else getting involved - Could I please request that you remember that opinions do not equal facts. There are a lot of opinions being disguised as facts here, and as a result the respectful nature we like to maintain across this forum is starting to erode slightly. Keep it respectful please.
That being said, it's an interesting debate, and one I've had many times with many people on here, and in real life. I'll weigh in with my own perspective, respectfully, for what it's worth.
The GRY and CTR are completely different cars, with completely different goals and completely different benchmarks of their "performance". I've spent hundreds, if not thousands of miles in both, stock and tuned examples, and they're chalk and cheese.
The CTR is a touring car for the road. It's razor sharp. It's potentially the greatest FWD chassis (or at least close) ever made, and in some way redefines what was considered possible in a road going FWD chassis. Because of this, where it shines, it shines a LOT brighter than a Yaris can even dream of.
The Yaris is a rally car for the road. It's the hammer to the Civic Type R's precision screwdriver. Its ability to redefine the levels of mechanical grip someone thinks are possible in a road car, are superb. No Civic Type R is ever going to keep up with a GR Yaris on a wet B road, or a rally stage. That's Yaris land.
Arguing about which is "better" or "faster", is like arguing which movie is better. It's completely irrelevant, and 100% personal preference.
I stand firmly on the side of the Civic, because I believe 4WD is a chassis that's inherently designed to help people who need help. Both FWD and especially RWD and far more flawed in their design language from a performance aspect, but precisely because of that require more skill to get right. That makes them more fun.
That doesn't mean the Yaris is bad, it just means its not my preference. People are allowed to like different things, and even if we don't agree, we can do so in a civil manner