Took a while for Blackhawk to dispatch it, but it finally shipped early on Wednesday morning, and then arrived today and is now fitted. I ended up having to pay a little more of an import fee (£57) than I'd hoped, bringing the total cost to ~£260.
Fitting wise, it is a little fiddly, but it can be done from inside the car without having to jack it up. Took me about 1.5 hours going slowly and methodically. The instructions in the FT video above are pretty much spot on; the only difference I would say, apart from being able to do it from above, is that it is probably easier to remove the rubber boot the opposite way from how he did it, and similar for reverse - when removing, I followed the video, and managed to tear the old boot slightly, but was still able to expose the linkage to disconnect it, then withdrew the whole shifter with the boot attached. When refitting the new one (it comes with a new boot), I found it easier to get the rubber around the linkage itself first, push the new shift lever into position and hook it up, then pull the boot back along the linkage and over the bottom of the connection with a pair of pliers and a small screwdriver. Just be careful not to yank it around too much and tear it. This was by far the only really difficult bit of the install - the rest is just trim removal and refitting. Oh and you will need a decent set of circlip pliers.
Verdict - this is not a massive improvement, but it is still noticeable. There is only a 10% reduction in throw, which means in the comparison video I took below, you can't really tell much difference. However, the shift action does feel nicer to me:
- The lever slots into each gate with a more satisfying mechanical feeling, a more positive feeling engagement
- It is certainly quicker to manipulate around the gate.
- It feels like the gear level might have slightly less side-to-side play than before, but I am not convinced, and can't see how that would be the case without changing something in the gearbox or linkage itself (such as stiffer MTEC return springs).
- There's a slightly heavier shift action, but that doesn't bother me because I'm not a wimpy girly-man (he is - Ed.).
Whether it's worth the cost and effort:
- If you are after a significant reduction in shift throw, then probably not. For that, you would probably be better off going for the Billetworkz kit, as it's probably not that much more expensive and offers a 33% reduction. However, consistent reports of rattling from those kits put me off, and that's something that would bother me, and it would be a pain to have to try and refund it to the US. There's also the risk that that much reduced throw might make the shift effort a lot higher, which might be more irritating.
- If, however, you're a bit of an idiot likes me who doesn't mind spending a bit too much more on subtle improvements to make things just "OEM+", then it's probably ideal. For me, the improvement in feel is more noticeable than the reduction in throw, and I don't feel too short changed, even having spent £260 on it - it just rounds off the car nicely and makes the already good shifter just a bit better. But I don't think I'd bother spending much more on it (think you're looking at around £320 from UK vendors).
I try to be objective about stuff and not too "omg guys, best thing evar!!!1!!1!!one!!", or fall into the trap of saying something is great to justify the time and effort doing it. So hopefully that's helpful.
Below is a comparison of stock vs. TRD, but as I said, it's difficult to convey such a minor improvement.