I get what you guys are saying but this is a GRY not an M or AMG or a shopping cart so the line between outright semi performance and a really good road based tyre is somewhat blurred. I have enjoyed the AD08R and they have done an occasional wet track day in lieu of the R888R which are lethal if a dog has urinated on the grass next to the road two suburbs away.
The GRY is not a grand tourer so NVH is relatively high anyway and the differences between a semi and good road tyre maybe not so obvious inside. I use the car as much as possible and you can read that any way you like. It is the only road car I have had that has spent most of its time on, around or beyond the limit.
The AD08R has been great for me but is increasingly noisy. Really noisy. Mine have about 15,000km on them and perhaps 5,000km left. I am considering swapping these to the OEM Enkeis to be my track tyres for next season and giving the R888R a rest. Plus I tore a big chuck out of one of the Toyos last sprint race when the black stuff went one way and I went the other. I want to check that out. Some of the sprint races are 200km away and currently I drive on the AD08R to the event and either use them or carry the R888R in the back and swap them closer to the venue. I wouldn't need to do that if I had the AD08Rs on the track rims. The R888R are even noisier and are more or less the same as a mud tyre on a 4wd.
I ran PS4S on my last two Ms and I really loved them but one track day and they wore very badly on the shoulders though on the road they were exceptionally good. Yes this is a set up issue but the M2 was very much a work car and was required to be friendly. While I could run PS4S on the GRY I do drive a lot of gravel and past experience shows the PS4S chip badly. My experience yours may vary.
The AD08R have held up to gravel road abuse remarkably well. Suprisingly well. Grip not so much...
So do I go for an AD09 which is reputedly a bit better all round than the AD08R or do I drop back to a road oriented tyre for some noise improvement and only a small loss in overall performance though a gain in wet weather traction? Having said all that the AD08R surprised me with its wet weather grip though that is probably just the GRY and awd.
I found this data on a UK site...
| Tyre | dry grip | wet grip | feedback | handling | wear | comfort |
| V107 | 95% | 95% | 100% | 100% | 70% | 70% |
| PS4S | 93% | 89% | 86% | 88% | 83% | 86% |
| A08R | 97% | 75% | 91% | 93% | 73% | 71% |
| AD09 | 98% | 72% | 93% | 98% | 73% | 73% |
| R888R | 96% | 70% | 88% | 92% | 67% | 67% |
And yes the tyres weren't tested one on one on the same car but averaged data and yes they tyres were all different sizes. I get that. I know from personal experience changing a tyre size on the same car with the same tyre doesn't result in the same or better results... To suggest that the R888R is only a bit less grippy in the wet compared to the AD08R is also showing that the data is not perfect. Unless of course they missed out the decimel point between the 7 and the 0. To be totally honest the R888R have felt a bit numb on the GRY so that bit is right.
So while I think there is not enough data on the V107 and the numbers seem too good to be true there is enough there for me to go that way. I will order some (I can do a deal for AUD300 f&b mate's rates) and see how they go.
For interest the costs for the tyres in that list vary from $300 for the V107 which is normally around $330 through to $450 for the PS4S with the others being around $340 ish.