GR Yaris Does anyone have both a Yaris and an electric car?

Gyp

Totally Hooked
Joined
Mar 2, 2022
Messages
523
Reaction score
785
At the moment we have our lovely Yaris, a Skoda Superb estate and an MX5 (and, err, 5 motorbikes) and don't do massive miles

Realistically we ought to reduce the fleet, and are considering letting go of the Skoda and MX5 and replacing them with 1 "family" car.

Having looked around a lot, we're being drawn to an electric Skoda, most likely a second-hand Enyaq,

But I'm worried.

Many moons ago we ran a gorgeous BMW E30 316i Lux and a tatty Citroen AX 1.4D. The BMW was glorious, and the Citroen wasn't, however whilst the BMW struggled to better 25mpg, it was a struggle to get the Citroen to do less than 80mpg.

Consequently we used the Citroen all the time and the BMW did a good job of sitting on the drive.

And my worry is if I replace the Skoda (which is already amazingly economical) with one that cost pennies to fuel, the same will happen with the Yaris. The marginal cost of use will become far greater.

Or maybe the savings from using the electric car a fair amount can be used to fund the fun in the Yaris.
 
If it's economics that are on your mind, then the Yaris isn't going to be the first set of keys to grab, but seeing as the Superb is already pretty economical I don't think it's going to have such a big impact going EV.

The contrast between a performance orientated manual ICE car and a comfort practicality focused EV is a massive appeal to me. What key I pick depends on the journey, not so much how much its gonna cost me, you might be the same.
 
Agree. Had my GRY parallel with our family EV over 3 years. Just grab the keys for the one most suitable for your trip. Regularly driving something contrasting makes one appreciate the GRY more.

(Still have the same today even though both are EV., driveline isn't all defining either)
 
Yes have both

IMG_7904.webp
 
Sorry as not able to comment from experience, but reading this with interest as currently have the same 3 car setup (family Skoda, a convertible and Yaris). I’d like to do exactly the same as you, but the main stalling point has been electric ‘ownership’ (leasing seems the best out of principle but my OH would rather own something outright that has already taken a depreciation hit, and like me doesn’t like the idea of finance) and the real ‘need’ as our Skoda is fairly economical.

I enjoy using the Yaris a lot more when I’ve been in the Skoda for the rest of the week, but if anything I’ve driven the Yaris too much recently and gotten too used to it. So I think your idea of saving it as a weekend car would be ideal.

I like your approach of a second hand Enyaq and that would tick the full ownership box for us too. Also on my list was a standard Ioniq 5. We do a 250 mile each way trip every month or so but mostly motorway so I still think an electric car would do the job given that we stop once, and be hassle free for the midweek shorter journeys.

The big issue is having the Yaris and a convertible as both do overlap for a weekend option. Roof down is nice but I much prefer the Yaris overall. So although it’s painful, perhaps the easiest thing is to ditch the MX5 and keep the Skoda and the Yaris. Economics won’t differ too much, as @ZN8 says, and you can fund more Yaris enjoyment with the lower running costs.
 
As for owning outright, biggest fear people have is getting battery issues. Tales of huge bills for replacement and massive degradation.

The former is something usually nobody pays by themselves out of pocket as warranty is still intact, and at least where I live car insurance can include extended coverage up to 12 years or 124000 miles. And if they had to pay themselves, options of used battery packs or repair usually are a better options, and UK as an automotive country has quite some options for that already which are only going to increase.

The latter, massive degradation tales, stem mostly from Nissan Leaf batteries that aren't water cooled and even there they are exaggerated outliers that get all attention. In recent years, more and more reports come from instances that do battery tests on thousands of cars that the batteries seem to last better then thought. Iirc average degradation is now around 1,24% per year, meaning that battery cars will last longer than most ICE car ownerships - classics excepted perhaps. Which brings us to the last point.

Goldman Sachs Research just reported that according to their predictions, by 2030 it will be cheaper to replace complete battery packs than engines, so if buying used today in 2025 or 2026 and manufacturer warranties expiring around 2030, financial risks are at large probably on par with ICE....
 
Last edited:
It would make a good selling point (at least for me) if batter is easily replaceable or reneweable by car maker if any issues occur.
Warranty is good option especially if its long enough (lets say 10-12 years) but the previous question is still evident when you're selling the car.

Some car models are interesting vehicles but due to high battery replacement cost they're quite gamble.
Especially as the driving might include rougher roads that can damage battery.
 
If it's economics that are on your mind, then the Yaris isn't going to be the first set of keys to grab, but seeing as the Superb is already pretty economical I don't think it's going to have such a big impact going EV.
If anything, that's a pretty good argument for keeping the Superb and not worrying about changing it.
 
Been there, done that…five times as an early EV adopter from 2014 and not had one now for two years. I see EVs as just another model type, rather than anything you can compare, because quite frankly they can’t compare to ICE. The evangelists will claim they can and will do everything better, but the reality is that EVs don’t - but they do have significant advantages if you have specific needs.

I don’t agree that battery deg is the number one concern, in the U.K. I would consider the charging network to be the main issue if you’re someone that wants to drive distances and it’s still absolutely pants. ICE’d bays, broken chargers, a myriad of schemes and networks. There have been improvements but I still see the queues and hear the tales of woe.

Insurance has become a little more realistic but there’s still a premium for most drivers over an ICE vehicle. Are they really cheaper to run? You’ll not find out until you’ve driven one over a period and worked out the equivalent MPG and where you charge plays such a massive part. On a run, public charging at peak times the Tesla could work out at 15 MPG.
 
If anything, that's a pretty good argument for keeping the Superb and not worrying about changing it.
If you like it, just keep it a bit longer. That what actually matters is that no new ICE are produced that will live and burn another 20 years, when an EV will be the far better choice especially towards the end of life when all thinkable infrastructure incl workshops and battery repair etc will be in place for them.

(Own both our EV outright btw...)
 
Sorry as not able to comment from experience, but reading this with interest as currently have the same 3 car setup (family Skoda, a convertible and Yaris). I’d like to do exactly the same as you, but the main stalling point has been electric ‘ownership’ (leasing seems the best out of principle but my OH would rather own something outright that has already taken a depreciation hit, and like me doesn’t like the idea of finance) and the real ‘need’ as our Skoda is fairly economical.
I'm not a fan of paying interest when I don't have to, but am not averse to taking the finance option when it makes sense.

The Skoda had a £4000 VAG contribution if I took out the PCP so I took it, then paid off the finance a few days later. I think I paid about £50 in interest but was still £3950 up on the deal.

While not the last word in luxury, the Kia EV3 entry model has a £3750 contribution, in place of the govt contribution at the moment, which makes it quite appealing.

...but then a brand-spanking Elroq Sportsline at nearly £10k off appeals too, though the £620 a year VED doesn't.

Ah, too much to think about. Perhaps I'll just pop out and get one of my Yaris alloys refurbed instead
 
I'm not a fan of paying interest when I don't have to, but am not averse to taking the finance option when it makes sense.

The Skoda had a £4000 VAG contribution if I took out the PCP so I took it, then paid off the finance a few days later. I think I paid about £50 in interest but was still £3950 up on the deal.

While not the last word in luxury, the Kia EV3 entry model has a £3750 contribution, in place of the govt contribution at the moment, which makes it quite appealing.

...but then a brand-spanking Elroq Sportsline at nearly £10k off appeals too, though the £620 a year VED doesn't.

Ah, too much to think about. Perhaps I'll just pop out and get one of my Yaris alloys refurbed instead
Absolutely …I took the 0% Yaris finance option as it was a no brainer! And if you enjoy something (cars) then it’s worth spending the money on for the enjoyment and hard to justify on paper anyway.
 
Have a Model 3 LR in addition to the Yaris.

They have different use cases though and I'll generally take the Yaris over the Tesla even for humdrum trips like commuting or nipping to the shops...and I don't even pay for the electricity for charging it!

Sometimes I'll take the Tesla just for fun as well though, or late at night going to pick my wife up from the airport or something. All warmed up in advance, no noise, just get in and drive.

Oh, and the stereo makes the Toyota's sound like a broken 1980s hearing aid :D

I will say I elect to take the Tesla more often compared to the A6 Avant it replaced, and that's nothing to do with the free charging (had a fuel card before too) but more becuse it is a much better car to actually drive than the rather leaden and, let's be honest, slow Audi.
 
Last edited:
I have a Polestar 4 Performance which is faster than my GR Yairs in a straight line. Its also lots of fun but you feel the weight. It’s much cheaper to use as a daily as charging is cheap here in Oslo, Norway, I can use the public charger and the cost is about 2-4 NOK pr 10 km. OBC is 22 kw. Using the GR the cost is 18-21 NOK pr liter.

I think all my cars have advantages and disadvantages but I enjoy them all😃
 
I have a V90 plugin hybrid as main car. With 70-90km of electric range, it's quite useable on daily runs. I currently drive around 40000km per year for work with 400+km single trips every week and lot's of smaller trips in between. I find the plug-in concept perfect for my specific use. I've tried a Polestar 3 performance for a month, but apart from it not being my cup of tea (500+ horsepower but I couldn't care less...), the full electric part just didn't work for me (even though I love the comfort of the electric drive).
My upcoming GRY will just be a fun summer car, which I find it perfect for. I would not want to drive it every single day.

That said, every single answer you get/got here, reflects everyones specific cases and wishes, so the only one to answer your own question is going to be you. If you ask me, I'd keep the Skoda. That's a perfect daily and doesn't require any investment in something new/different (why would you?). Keeping the GRY for fun drives besides the Skoda would make it more special, at least from my perspective.
 
Get a hybrid instead?
At one point that was part of the plan, and the missus especially was determined that we should get a Rav4 plug in. Of course so we didn't downgrade the interior compared with the Skoda it would have to be the GR sport version rather than the Design and have the panoramic roof.

Which typically puts the used ones around £40k+, and subject to the higher VED.

And the other thing really putting me off was the servicing cost. The huge increases in Toyota servicing in the time I've had the Yaris have been somewhat eye-watering and, even though the Rav is less expensive to service than the Yaris, I can't afford (don't want to pay for) 2 lots of Toyota servicing.
 
That said, every single answer you get/got here, reflects everyones specific cases and wishes, so the only one to answer your own question is going to be you. If you ask me, I'd keep the Skoda. That's a perfect daily and doesn't require any investment in something new/different (why would you?). Keeping the GRY for fun drives besides the Skoda would make it more special, at least from my perspective.
My Superb Sportline 1.4 DSG Combi is a magnificent car. Comfortable, well appointed, relaxed, smooth, easy going, massive luggage capacity and, as I drive it like a limo rather than a sports car and am rarely in a hurry, will return well over 50mpg on a run. It even has cute party tricks like shutting down 2 cylinders and running as a 700cc twin when we're cruising. Simply clever.

It is a truly magnificent car and I cannot fault it.

It does that itself.

Since I've had it there have been a few things that have gone wrong. First the mechatronic controller for the gearbox [1]. Then the navigation system, with the GPS insisting that I was always about 50m west of my true position [2]. Then the headlamp level wiring so the lights pointed at the road immediately in front of the car [3] and then the gearbox synchromesh [4].

These faults all caused real big problems and I've kind of lost trust in the car. My son has a Golf that's a couple of years older (same platform) so I can kind of forsee the future with the problems that he is having. It's true that the Skoda may go on forever with nothing else ever going wrong, but I'm worried that it might not and the cost to fix the problems hasn't been pocket money.

[1] Fixed under warranty.
[2] reported under warranty but took 3 attempts to fix, eventually out of warranty.
[3] Repaired by local independent rather than requiring the loom to be replaced.
[4] Car was with Skoda main dealer and it took them 7 months to fix it as they kept replacing the mechatronic unit.
 
My Superb Sportline 1.4 DSG Combi is a magnificent car. Comfortable, well appointed, relaxed, smooth, easy going, massive luggage capacity and, as I drive it like a limo rather than a sports car and am rarely in a hurry, will return well over 50mpg on a run. It even has cute party tricks like shutting down 2 cylinders and running as a 700cc twin when we're cruising. Simply clever.

It is a truly magnificent car and I cannot fault it.

It does that itself.

Since I've had it there have been a few things that have gone wrong. First the mechatronic controller for the gearbox [1]. Then the navigation system, with the GPS insisting that I was always about 50m west of my true position [2]. Then the headlamp level wiring so the lights pointed at the road immediately in front of the car [3] and then the gearbox synchromesh [4].

These faults all caused real big problems and I've kind of lost trust in the car. My son has a Golf that's a couple of years older (same platform) so I can kind of forsee the future with the problems that he is having. It's true that the Skoda may go on forever with nothing else ever going wrong, but I'm worried that it might not and the cost to fix the problems hasn't been pocket money.

[1] Fixed under warranty.
[2] reported under warranty but took 3 attempts to fix, eventually out of warranty.
[3] Repaired by local independent rather than requiring the loom to be replaced.
[4] Car was with Skoda main dealer and it took them 7 months to fix it as they kept replacing the mechatronic unit.
I had a Superb 280 L&K for a couple of years. Genuinely a brilliant family car, even if the ride and handling was a bit iffy.

Not sure I could put up with 150hp (or whatever) in one though 😂
 
Back
Top