GR Yaris Which short shifter? Forge, Airtec, Foresight (non-CAE, etc.)

Which short shifter?


  • Total voters
    32

DobiLux

Absorbed member
Joined
Jan 25, 2023
Messages
52
Reaction score
48
What experiences have you had with the non-CAE short shifters?

- With the Foresight, for example, I read from someone that the screws loosened after a few trackdays, but that could also be because you didn't stick to the Nm for tightening.
- I've also read that after installing some short shifters, the gearshift feel is bad.

What experiences have you had?
Which brand is recommendable?

(This topic is explicitly only about short shifters that do not correspond to the CAE design).


Edit:
I would have rather posted this thread under "Engines & Performance", but you can't start a poll there (bug?).
Maybe a moderator can move it.
 
Have Foresight, no issues.

Do again, probably Forge as it looks nicely done and is adjustble. But no actual experience.

Ref feel, I already thought the foresight was pretty short at 35% less, almost notchy. Higher knob/longer shaft fixed that. Airtec much to short imho.
 
At least with CAE have seen few misshifts so not sure if thats really smart idea with this car and valve rockers
 
At least with CAE have seen few misshifts so not sure if thats really smart idea with this car and valve rockers
That was also a thought I had before, but apparently the short shifters mentioned above only reduce the travel from top <-> bottom, but not from left <-> right.
So it shouldn't change the danger of a misshift much, as long as the shift feeling remains good. (At least that's how I imagine it...)

(I know the CAE is probably by far the best, but at the moment I want to keep the interior more or less standard, at least no holes where a passenger can drop something in it. :rolleyes::ROFLMAO: I have already seen that someone has built a 3D print for closing most of the gaps.)
 
That was also a thought I had before, but apparently the short shifters mentioned above only reduce the travel from top <-> bottom, but not from left <-> right.
So it shouldn't change the danger of a misshift much, as long as the shift feeling remains good. (At least that's how I imagine it...)

Indeed. If you put a higher knob or extend the shaft, you effectively increase the distance left<=>right while keeping fore<=>aft shorter with the shortshift.
 
At least with CAE have seen few misshifts so not sure if thats really smart idea with this car and valve rockers
I've been driving the CAE since the beginning. Not a misshift yet... Everyone who has tried it loves it.

Often you can't always blame a fundamental lack of talent on certain parts, like all the DSG automatic boys who can't handle manual transmission :).
 
I've been driving the CAE since the beginning. Not a misshift yet... Everyone who has tried it loves it.

Often you can't always blame a fundamental lack of talent on certain parts, like all the DSG automatic boys who can't handle manual transmission :).
Well if it happened your engine would be gone. Only needs to happen once, even if it happens to 1% in a moment of weakness... It's still a real risk. Very tight between gates sideways.... Don't think DSG guys are the ones installing these....
 
Well if it happened your engine would be gone. Only needs to happen once, even if it happens to 1% in a moment of weakness... It's still a real risk. Very tight between gates sideways.... Don't think DSG guys are the ones installing these....
Its not my first car. But thanks for the Info :D

The internet is full of people giving relationship advice, mostly single people... It's the same with cars. Of most of the "misshifters" I've read, it was original. So if someone messes up with the CAE, it doesn't have to be because of that. I can only speak for myself and the part is an asset.

No attack on you, really. I mean that in general.πŸ‘πŸ»

For all Parts to buy...... You should try it yourself and then preferably with someone who has set the part correctly.
 
Its not my first car. But thanks for the Info :D

The internet is full of people giving relationship advice, mostly single people... It's the same with cars. Of most of the "misshifters" I've read, it was original. So if someone messes up with the CAE, it doesn't have to be because of that. I can only speak for myself and the part is an asset.

No attack on you, really. I mean that in general.πŸ‘πŸ»

For all Parts to buy...... You should try it yourself and then preferably with someone who has set the part correctly.
Just stating fact, it is very closely spaced, so it is reasonable to state risk is higher. Probably more risk again if driven on a bumpy surface without race seats. Or when daily driven.

There are many more stock cars so equal risk would mean big majority would be stock cars misshifting. But true, don't have the hard stats.

Has nothing to do with satisfaction or how much you like it. Happy you love it. I'm pleased with my shortsshift, extended shifter and spacers that raise the whole, it's something inbetween. CAE bit much for a daily imho which yours isn't afaik. Horses for courses. Like OP who didn't ask for CAE ;)
 
OP Apologies for the thread hyjack, but would you happen to know the difference between the CAE and coolerworx?
Honestly, that may sound stupid now.... but the Coolerworx is cheaper and my head says again, there is a compromise and I hate compromises :).

But purely from the pictures, it looks like the difference is only in the design.

CAE has TÜV... its important in Germany.
 
Just stating fact, it is very closely spaced, so it is reasonable to state risk is higher. Probably more risk again if driven on a bumpy surface without race seats. Or when daily driven.

There are many more stock cars so equal risk would mean big majority would be stock cars misshifting. But true, don't have the hard stats.

Has nothing to do with satisfaction or how much you like it. Happy you love it. I'm pleased with my shortsshift, extended shifter and spacers that raise the whole, it's something inbetween. CAE bit much for a daily imho which yours isn't afaik. Horses for courses. Like OP who didn't ask for CAE ;)
For my part, I can't see any more risk than the original.
On the contrary, shifting is so safe/precise.
If you screw that up, you don't shift, you stir like crazy.😳 Many people stir ...

But it's the same with blonde women or red-haired women etc. Tastes are different and everyone feels differently.

For me... its much more safe than OEM. It feels saddled, just awesome.

You're right, my car isn't a daily. I would still put it in the Daily though. I don't see any disadvantages, on the contrary.

But everyone as he thinks. I'm not bad at all. You have to decide for yourself. So I leave the thread, sorry to the creator :).
 
I have both @Greenthumb 's and @Onehp 's problems, ie I need to have one (in its most raw and statement-looking colour) and my other half hates it and how it would make the car look.

Even worse for me, I haven't got it; yet...

Worst of all, @DobiLux politely yet clearly asked for no references to the CAE or similar designs. So far he got:
  • a passionate & detailed discussion on the CAE one πŸ˜΅β€πŸ’«πŸ˜€πŸ«£
  • analogies with DSG automatic boys & relationship advice by singles πŸ™ƒ
  • references to πŸ‘±β€β™€οΈ & πŸ‘©β€πŸ¦°
We're a funny bunch 🀣 Nice problems to have.
 
I have both @Greenthumb 's and @Onehp 's problems, ie I need to have one (in its most raw and statement-looking colour) and my other half hates it and how it would make the car look.

Even worse for me, I haven't got it; yet...

Worst of all, @DobiLux politely yet clearly asked for no references to the CAE or similar designs. So far he got:
  • a passionate & detailed discussion on the CAE one πŸ˜΅β€πŸ’«πŸ˜€πŸ«£
  • analogies with DSG automatic boys & relationship advice by singles πŸ™ƒ
  • references to πŸ‘±β€β™€οΈ & πŸ‘©β€πŸ¦°
We're a funny bunch 🀣 Nice problems to have.
Haha, thanks for the summary 😁

Let's just say that I am aware that the CAE design is probably the best in terms of feel.
However, I'm quite sure my girlfriend will lose things in the holes it creates. πŸ˜† So it's not an option for now.
(And >750€ is not a small amount of money either).
 
Last edited:
seems there is clear winner, or not! Quite many opinions on each!
I'm quite happy with stock shifter but TBH no experience on short shifters or CAE - just speculating based on the videos seen (mostly by experienced drivers) .
I have big hands so stock feels quite "quick" in my world already.
 
One of the most experienced trackday drivers here has tried CAE many times on a friends car (properly setup) and my shortshift setup as described above, and he chose to copy mine with motivation, amongst other reasons, less likelyhood for misshifting. So not just me then. I would like CAE etc on a track drive/smooth roads, but not on a back road drive full with bumps as is the case here all the time. Just my opinion and best advice is to try both and see what you like.
 
One of the most experienced trackday drivers here has tried CAE many times on a friends car (properly setup) and my shortshift setup as described above, and he chose to copy mine with motivation, amongst other reasons, less likelyhood for misshifting. So not just me then. I would like CAE etc on a track drive/smooth roads, but not on a back road drive full with bumps as is the case here all the time. Just my opinion and best advice is to try both and see what you like.
Thank you for the feedback :)
So what is your setup (which exact parts from which brands apart from the Foresight short shifter), if you don't mind me asking?
 
I have foresight, feels more like 50% less throw, rather than advertised 35% I believe. Very nice for spirited driving, but feels as excessive force is needed while cruising. Also trying to be very gentle while oil is cold. I'd suggest this or similar design if you dont have all the mounts stiffened.
 
Back
Top