GR86 Engine Failure

Are you concerned about the GR86 engine failure stories emerging?

  • 1. Not concerned - if it breaks Toyota will fix it

    Votes: 48 39.0%
  • 2. Slightly concerned - but not losing any sleep over it

    Votes: 54 43.9%
  • 3. I’m getting worried - I want to use my car on track

    Votes: 13 10.6%
  • 4. I’m very worried - I’d planned a lot of mods and lots of track use

    Votes: 2 1.6%
  • 5. I’m that worried I’m cancelling - and off to buy something else

    Votes: 6 4.9%

  • Total voters
    123
The new information was that he dropped the sump and found RTV in the pickup that could not be attributed to sealant from the sump...
One of the Japanese tweets suggested their 86's timing chain ingested some from the timing cover and it ended up in the sump/strainer.
 
The CEO just got back from Costco with some gasket material , can anyone post a scale drawing of the sump pan face for a GT86 (should be same size) so I can practice making decent gaskets that don’t need RTV 🤔. If I get this sorted I’m happy to offer to Zoo members at cost, plus PP , payment by PayPal Family and Friends 👍

A05D55C1-6E35-4394-953A-755F4F7115B6.webp
 
Posted on a Facebook GR8/BRZ forum, guy dropped the oil pan and this is what it looked like 🤔

32BED02F-434C-4838-ABE5-4432F819DFB8.webp
 
The problem with dropping the oil pan and re-sealing is that it's not a guaranteed fix.
- Firstly, the problem is that the there was too much sealant applied. If a computer controlled robot in a factory hasn't been able to seal it properly, then it seems just as likely that anyone who decides to do it themselves, lying on their back, in their own garage, will also be at risk of applying it incorrectly. And thus reattaching their oil pan thinking they've solved the issue, when perhaps they haven't.
- Secondly, I'm pretty sure that evidence has been found of sealing material of a different colour, which means it's not just come from the sump/block interface, but possibly from somewhere else (heads, cam covers, etc). If that's the case, there's no way of rectifying that without tearing the engine down completely.

Having said that, I think perhaps we should all step back and calm down about this. Although lots of people are reporting sealant debris in their oil pans, there have actually only been a few instances of engine failures, and only one of them that we know of where the warranty was initially refused (and that was not Toyota's fault, but the fault of a rogue dealer really). I am not going to lose too much sleep over it. I'm just going to drive the car and maintain it to the best of my ability. If the engine goes pop, it will be covered by warranty.

The good thing is that the controversy over the case in America is that Toyota wont really have a leg to stand on refusing any such claims in the future - not that I think it would be a problem anyway. As I said, that case in particular seems to be more about a shitty dealer, than the corporate response.
 
Last edited:
Exactly this. I'll let it get to temp, run it in as per requirements, do a 1000 mile oil change to be sure then drive it how I want.
 
The problem with dropping the oil pan and re-sealing is that it's not a guaranteed fix.
- Firstly, the problem is that the there was too much sealant applied. If a computer controlled robot in a factory hasn't been able to seal it properly, then it seems just as likely that anyone who decides to do it themselves, lying on their back, in their own garage, will also be at risk of applying it incorrectly. And thus reattaching their oil pan thinking they've solved the issue, when perhaps they haven't.
- Secondly, I'm pretty sure that evidence has been found of sealing material of a different colour, which means it's not just come from the sump/block interface, but possibly from somewhere else (heads, cam covers, etc). If that's the case, there's no way of rectifying that without tearing the engine down completely.

Having said that, I think perhaps we should all step back and calm down about this. Although lots of people are reporting sealant debris in their oil pans, there have actually only been a few instances of engine failures, and only one of them that we know of where the warranty was initially refused (and that was not Toyota's fault, but the fault of a rogue dealer really). I am not going to lose too much sleep over it. I'm just going to drive the car and maintain it to the best of my ability. If the engine goes pop, it will be covered by warranty.

The good thing is that the controversy over the case in America is that Toyota wont really have a leg to stand on refusing any such claims in the future - not that I think it would be a problem anyway. As I said, that case in particular seems to be more about a shitty dealer, than the corporate response.
Yes, I reckon that's a pretty accurate and fair overview of the current situation (based on the information currently in the public domain).

However, as a lapsed (i.e. retired) Lawyer, I still believe that the questions posed in my post at #89 above are ones which should be raised with TGB at the appropriate time - I am still surprised that the UK-based motoring media has yet to give the story any coverage.
 
Last edited:
Yes, I reckon that's a pretty accurate and fair overview of the current situation (based on the information currently in the public domain).

However, as a lapsed (i.e. retired) Lawyer, I still believe that the questions posed in my post at #90 above are ones which should be raised with TGB at the appropriate time - I am still surprised that the UK-based motoring media has yet to give the story any coverage.
Probably under embargo. To my knowledge, the press cars turned up, we saw them for a day or two then it went quiet. It's weird no one has even seen them driving about.
 
Probably under embargo. To my knowledge, the press cars turned up, we saw them for a day or two then it went quiet. It's weird no one has even seen them driving about.
I am not sure that you are right about an embargo - after all, Autocar published this article about the issue with the bZ4X on Monday and that is a not dissimilar situation:

However, concerns about the RTV sealant/possible engine failure issue might explain why the press cars do not appear to be out and about at the moment.
 
I am not sure that you are right about an embargo - after all, Autocar published this article about the issue with the bZ4X on Monday and that is a not dissimilar situation:

However, concerns about the RTV sealant/possible engine failure issue might explain why the press cars do not appear to be out and about at the moment.
More embargo on UK reviews, especially as it's not released here yet. Unless one let go during test and they pulled it all.
 
Hey guys, I just had this response from the online team.
Thanks for your email enquiry and your for your patience throughout, I would like to confirm that we are indeed here but not in the same place as your GR86. I appreciate your feedback on the matter and do understand your frustrations regarding additional communication of vehicle delivery.

I personally don't have any commentary on the RTV sealant as I'm far from technical, may I ask where this information has come from so I can look into it? It would also be difficult to answer your question around the engine blowing up as this would likely depend on how the car has been driven. The GR86 will come with Toyota's 3 year manufacturers warranty however this is not extended to track use.

I do hope this has helped and please do let us know if there is anything else I can try to assist with.

Could someone provide me with good links I can reply with to toyota online please?
 
Hey guys, I just had this response from the online team.


Could someone provide me with good links I can reply with to toyota online please?
Complete shambles this is. They have no idea about anything we are talking about and you won’t get any communication from them that will be helpful.
 
Just my 2 cents: you are wasting your time with their online support. The fact that s/he does not have heard anything about the problem already tells you everything you need to know. These people usually just do their regular social media job without a special dedication to their employer and its products. Today they will answer you if the GR86 has heated seats and tomorrow they will help you to find out if the Samsung microwave Pyrostar X74-T is also available in white...

Even if you provide links and further information the answer will remain more or less the same and will not get you a single step forward. The person will and can not comment on this. I would assume they are even trained to stay away from providing any comments on such topics. You will be told that your matter will be forwarded to whatever department and I bet you will never hear anything useful again afterwards.
 
Hey guys, I just had this response from the online team.


Could someone provide me with good links I can reply with to toyota online please?
Hang on ‘Toyota’s 3 year manufacturers warranty’?? Isn’t it 10 years??
 
Just my 2 cents: you are wasting your time with their online support. The fact that s/he does not have heard anything about the problem already tells you everything you need to know. These people usually just do their regular social media job without a special dedication to their employer and its products. Today they will answer you if the GR86 has heated seats and tomorrow they will help you to find out if the Samsung microwave Pyrostar X74-T is also available in white...

Even if you provide links and further information the answer will remain more or less the same and will not get you a single step forward. The person will and can not comment on this. I would assume they are even trained to stay away from providing any comments on such topics. You will be told that your matter will be forwarded to whatever department and I bet you will never hear anything useful again afterwards.
That may be the case but.... Once I provide them with information they can no longer proof no one told them of the problem. If my engine blows and they claim ignorance I can proof I made them aware
 
This is a decent read, and sums up where we are at this point in time. The “Aftermarket Gasket” idea appears to be getting more mentions as potentially a way of sorting this issue out. As other folk have said applying the right amount of RTV by hand is not as easy as it sounds.


On a personal note I’m interested in this issue but not worried about it on U.K. cars which will be at least a year into production run if not two. I’m sure Toyota will have recalibrated “Bender” the engine building robot by then. As don’t do anything ”mechanical“ myself , with all servicing done at my local dealership (who I currently have a good relationship with) I will let them deal with any issues which may arise. I will check oil regularly and any signs of RTV on the dipstick will be reported to the local service manager and Toyota U.K.
 
That may be the case but.... Once I provide them with information they can no longer proof no one told them of the problem. If my engine blows and they claim ignorance I can proof I made them aware
Thats right.
If you dont do anything, you can be sure nothing will be forwarded.

But if you provide them the links, something MAY happen.
Since its not a big effort to send them some links, i would just do it...
 
Interesting that they are now saying the warranty does not cover track use. I've got 2 emails from Toyota online saying the warranty is the same as the GR Yaris and will cover track use.
 
Back
Top